Farm service guides and a state-by-state directory for farmers and ranchersA farm.FM network site · Farm news →
AgServicesDirectoryWho to call, state by state
Home › Guides › Worksheets, Checklists & Calibration Guides › Farm Insurance Agent Interview Checklist

Farm Insurance Agent Interview Checklist

Choosing a farm insurance agent is a hiring decision, and these questions help you learn who actually understands barns, livestock, equipment and seasonal income before you sign anything.

Worksheets, Checklists & Calibration Guides3 min read758 words

In short

  • Confirm the agent is licensed in your state and writes real farm accounts, not just homeowners policies.
  • Ask how claims are handled, who you call and what the agent does after you call.
  • Get quotes, exclusions and promises in writing and compare identical limits and deductibles.

Start with who the agent represents

Some agents work for a single company and some can quote with several. Neither is wrong, but you should know which you are talking to. Ask how many carriers they place farm business with, and whether farm and ranch accounts are most of their book or a sideline next to auto and homeowners policies. Ask how long they have handled agricultural accounts and whether they hold any farm-specific designations. Your state department of insurance has a license lookup, so confirm the agent is licensed in your state before you share financial details. If the answer to every question is a smooth pivot back to a bundled homeowners discount, keep looking.

Ask what they know about your kind of operation

A cow-calf outfit, a grain farm, a dairy and a pumpkin patch with a hayride have very different exposures. Describe yours in plain terms and watch whether the agent asks follow-up questions. Good ones ask about custom work you do for neighbors, hired labor, grain stored for others, livestock on leased ground, farm stands, agritourism, chemical application and where you haul. Ask for the names of two or three clients with similar operations who will take a call. Do not accept a list of clients who are nothing like you.

Dig into how claims actually go

Ask who you call when a barn roof peels off at night, and whether a person answers or a call center does. Ask how the agent behaves during a claim: do they file it, follow it, argue with the adjuster when needed? Ask about the last farm claim they worked on, with details left out, and how long it took to settle. Ask whether the company has adjusters who understand farm losses such as livestock death, spoiled stored grain or equipment valuations. Claims service is the product. The premium is just the entry fee.

Test their review process

Ask how often they sit down and review coverage with you, and whether that includes a walk around the place. An agent who has never seen your shop, bins and shelter belts is guessing. Ask what documents they need from you: an equipment list, a building inventory, a schedule of livestock, a record of leased acres and any custom work. Ask how they handle changes mid-year, such as a new grain bin, a hired hand or a changed lease, and how fast they confirm the change in writing.

Talk about money plainly

Ask for a written breakdown of premium by coverage, the deductibles, the sublimits and any exclusions. Ask which items are covered at replacement cost and which at actual cash value, since that difference matters when a ten-year-old tractor is lost. Ask about payment plans that line up with your cash flow, because many farm incomes come in lumps. Ask what the agent is paid and whether any fees apply beyond the premium. Rules and products vary by state and carrier, so treat every answer as something to verify against the policy itself.

Get the answers in writing

Verbal promises evaporate at claim time. After the interview, ask for a written summary of what was quoted, what was excluded and what the agent said they would do. Compare quotes from at least two agents on the same limits and deductibles, otherwise you are comparing prices for different things. Read the exclusions page twice. If something you were told is not in the document, ask for it to be added or corrected. If an agent resists putting things in writing, that tells you what you need to know. Your state department of insurance can answer questions about complaint history and licensing.

Watch for warning signs

Pay attention to how the agent behaves in the first meeting. Do they listen more than they talk? Do they return calls within a day? Do they push you to decide quickly or promise the lowest price before seeing your operation? Be cautious of anyone who says a policy covers everything. No policy does. Ask what the agent would change about your current program and why. A good agent will name real trade-offs, such as a higher deductible in exchange for lower premium, and will admit when a coverage is not available. Trust your read of the person, because you will be working with them after a loss.

Find providers near you

Pick your state to see vets, custom operators, dealers, elevators and other farm services.

Keep reading