Farm service guides and a state-by-state directory for farmers and ranchersA farm.FM network site · Farm news →
AgServicesDirectoryWho to call, state by state
Home › Guides › Worksheets, Checklists & Calibration Guides › Crop Insurance Decision Worksheet

Crop Insurance Decision Worksheet

Choosing a crop insurance plan and coverage level comes down to your yield history, your costs, and how much loss you can carry yourself. Here is a plain way to compare.

Worksheets, Checklists & Calibration Guides3 min read709 words

In short

  • Set your affordable loss first, then price coverage against it in dollars per acre.
  • Compare every plan at the same coverage level so the guarantees line up.
  • Calendar the closing and reporting dates, and keep your yield records clean.

Start with what you can afford to lose

Before looking at plans, write down the loss your farm can absorb in a bad year without missing a loan payment or selling land. That number is more useful than any quote. Take your total cost to put the crop in the ground, subtract the cash reserves you would be willing to spend, and what remains is the gap insurance should fill. Example: 500 acres with 450 dollars an acre in costs is 225,000 dollars at risk. If you can absorb 40,000 dollars, the gap is 185,000 dollars. Hold that figure beside every quote. Rules, plans, and subsidies are set by USDA's Risk Management Agency and sold through approved agents, so confirm current details with an agent or the agency.

Gather the records the agent will ask about

Pull together your yield history for each crop and county, your acres by farm unit, share arrangements with landlords, and your cost records. A clean multi-year history helps the agent build your guarantee accurately. Missing records can force the use of default yields, which may be lower than what you really raise. Write down any years that were unusual, such as drought or flood, and whether your history reflects them. If you recently added ground, note what the prior operator's yields were, if you can document them. Bring a field map. Agents and adjusters speak in units and farm numbers, so match your own labels to theirs before the sales deadline.

Compare plans by the question each answers

Yield-based plans protect bushels, and revenue-based plans protect bushels times price. Write one line for each option offered on your crop and answer three things. What triggers a payment? What price or yield is the guarantee based on? What does the plan do if prices rise after planting? Do not guess here. Ask the agent to run each plan at the same coverage level and show the guarantee in dollars per acre. A plan that looks cheaper may simply be guaranteeing less. Put the guarantees side by side on the worksheet so the choice is clear on paper instead of in a sales pitch.

Test coverage levels against your gap

Take the dollars-per-acre guarantee and subtract your deductible, which is the share of the guarantee you carry yourself. Example: a 700 dollar an acre revenue guarantee at 75 percent coverage protects 525 dollars an acre, so the first 175 dollars an acre of loss is yours. On 500 acres, that deductible is 87,500 dollars. Compare it to the 40,000 dollars you said you could absorb. If your deductible is larger than your comfort level, price a higher coverage level and see what the extra premium buys. Higher coverage costs more per acre and the cost does not rise evenly, so ask for the actual quotes rather than guessing.

Add-ons, units, and timing

Ask about optional endorsements that cover some of the deductible, and about how units are set, since separate units can pay on one bad field while a combined unit averages good fields against bad. Write down the sales closing date, the acreage reporting date, and the production reporting date for each crop, and put them on the wall calendar. Missed deadlines are a common and expensive mistake. Confirm planting dates and any final planting date rules for your crop with your agent. If you rent ground on shares, confirm that the landlord's interest is handled correctly in the policy.

Mistakes to avoid

Do not pick a plan because the neighbor did. His land, history, and loan are not yours. Do not buy on premium alone. Do not skip the records step and then complain about the guarantee. Do not wait until closing week to call, because good agents are busy and so are you. Check the agent's license through your state department of insurance, and read the policy provisions on prevented planting and replant, because they affect real money. Keep the signed worksheet in the same folder as your acreage reports so you can reconstruct your reasoning next year.

Find providers near you

Pick your state to see vets, custom operators, dealers, elevators and other farm services.

Keep reading