In short
- Cost per hour equals yearly ownership cost plus repairs, divided by hours used.
- Compare against a newer machine and a custom rate from your region.
- Count downtime at planting and harvest as part of the real repair cost.
What the worksheet is for
Depreciation is the loss in value of a machine as it ages and wears. Replacement planning asks a different question: when does the total yearly cost of keeping this machine climb above the cost of a newer one? This is a management tool, and it does not substitute for tax depreciation, which follows rules set by the IRS and your state. Ask your accountant how tax depreciation schedules and any expensing options apply to you. For the worksheet, we use plain numbers you can verify: purchase price, what it would sell for now, hours or acres per year, repair bills, and fuel.
Step one: gather the numbers
For each machine write down the purchase price, the year you bought it, the current hours, and an honest estimate of today's sale value. Look at recent auction results or ask a dealer for an appraisal, and remember that asking prices are not selling prices. Add up repair and maintenance receipts for the past few years. Add the yearly cost of insurance and storage if you pay for them. Estimate annual use in hours. If your records are thin, start keeping them now. A folder with one page per machine is enough.
Step two: figure yearly ownership cost
Take the loss in value over a period and divide by the years. Example: a tractor bought at 120,000 dollars that would sell for 84,000 dollars today after four years has lost 36,000 dollars, or 9,000 dollars a year. Add interest on the money tied up. If the average value is about 102,000 dollars and your borrowing or opportunity cost is 6 percent, that is 6,120 dollars a year. Add insurance and housing, say 1,500 dollars. Ownership cost is then 9,000 plus 6,120 plus 1,500, which is 16,620 dollars a year. These figures are examples, so use your own.
Step three: add operating and repair costs
Add the yearly repair bill, including the cost of downtime when the machine is broken at planting or harvest. Example: 4,200 dollars in repairs and 300 hours of use. Repairs per hour are 4,200 divided by 300, or 14 dollars. Ownership cost per hour is 16,620 divided by 300, or 55.40 dollars. Together, that is 69.40 dollars per hour before fuel and labor. Compare that with the cost per hour of a newer machine, calculated the same way, or with the custom rate for the same work from a university Extension custom rate survey. Rates vary by region.
Step four: look for the crossover
Plot or list the yearly total cost for each year of ownership. In the early years, depreciation is large and repairs are small. In later years, depreciation flattens and repairs rise. The best time to replace is often near the bottom of the combined cost curve, but timing risk matters too. A machine that breaks during harvest costs more than the repair bill. Ask yourself how many acres ride on it and whether a loaner or rental is available. If a failure would cost you a crop window, a younger machine may be worth more than the arithmetic shows.
Check the market and the manual
Before you decide, ask two dealers what the trade-in would be and when the value tends to fall off for that model. Read the manufacturer's manual for the service intervals, and compare against what you have actually done. Missing service shortens life and cuts trade value. Ask your lender about financing terms, and your accountant about tax effects of selling, trading, or keeping. Consider whether a different size would suit your acreage now. Many farms run machines that are too big for their ground because the original purchase was made at a different scale.
Mistakes to avoid
Do not use the original price as the value today. Do not ignore the cost of the money tied up. Do not skip downtime from the repair column. Do not buy a machine because the old one is paid off and looks tired, without running the numbers on both. Do not treat the tax schedule as the real value, since the two can differ a lot. Revisit the sheet each year after harvest while the repair receipts are still in the pickup.
Find providers near you
Pick your state to see vets, custom operators, dealers, elevators and other farm services.
