In short
- Put both offers on one page with the same period and the same assumptions.
- Test hour limits, excess charges, and the end-of-term price in real dollars.
- Get buyout terms and repair duties in writing, and review them with your accountant.
Know what each option really is
A purchase gives you ownership, the machine's trade or sale value at the end, and responsibility for repairs. A lease usually gives lower payments for a set term, with limits on hours, wear, and condition, and then a choice at the end: return the machine, buy it at a stated price, or renew. Some contracts called leases are really financing with a purchase at the end. Ask the dealer or lender to say in writing which one you are being offered. Ask your accountant how each is treated for tax, since that depends on your situation and changes with the law.
Gather the offers in the same form
Ask for a written quote for both options on the same machine. For the purchase, record the price, down payment, interest rate, loan term, and monthly or annual payment. For the lease, record the term, payment, any down payment or fees, the annual hour limit, the charge for extra hours, the end-of-term purchase price, and who pays for insurance and repairs. Write everything on one page with two columns. Missing numbers are a warning sign. If the dealer cannot supply a figure, ask for it before you do anything else.
Run the total cost over the same period
Choose a period, such as five years. Example: buying a machine with 20,000 dollars down and payments of 18,000 dollars a year totals 20,000 plus 5 times 18,000, which is 110,000 dollars. Suppose you estimate it would be worth 60,000 dollars at year five. The net cost is 50,000 dollars. A lease with 4,000 dollars down and payments of 14,000 dollars a year totals 4,000 plus 70,000, or 74,000 dollars, with nothing left at the end unless you buy. Here buying looks cheaper by 24,000 dollars, but only if the 60,000 dollar value is real. Test with a lower number.
Hours, wear, and the fine print
Hours are the biggest lease trap. If the contract allows 400 hours a year and you run 550, the overage charge per hour can erase the savings. Example: 150 extra hours times a charge of 40 dollars an hour is 6,000 dollars a year. Read what counts as excess wear, and what the return inspection involves. Ask about early termination penalties, restrictions on custom work, and insurance requirements. Ask who handles major repairs and whether a warranty covers the whole term. Read the contract before you sign and have your lawyer look at it if the amount is large.
Cash flow and interest
Compare what each choice does to your cash flow, not just to total cost. A lease may free money for inputs in a tight year. A purchase may allow a larger tax deduction in the year of purchase, depending on current rules, which your accountant should confirm. Ask your lender how each option affects your balance sheet and borrowing capacity. Check the interest rate on a purchase against what you would earn or save by using your cash elsewhere. If the lender offers a low rate only for a certain term, ask about the penalty for early payoff.
Mistakes to avoid
Do not compare monthly payments without comparing terms and end values. Do not guess your annual hours; look at your logs. Do not assume a lease is cheaper because the first payment is smaller. Do not overlook custom-hire income, which can push hours beyond lease limits. Do not accept a verbal promise about buyout price or repairs. Get it in the contract. Finally, check the dealer's terms with a second source, such as your lender or Farm Credit office, before signing.
Find providers near you
Pick your state to see vets, custom operators, dealers, elevators and other farm services.
