In short
- Give every provider the same written description of the job before they quote.
- Put quotes in a grid, convert to a common unit, and total every cost.
- Weigh timing, insurance and risk, and be careful with the very low bid.
Make Every Provider Quote the Same Job
Quotes cannot be compared if each provider is pricing something different. Write a short description of the work and send it to everyone: acres or head, field locations, timing, materials, access, and any special conditions. Ask each to quote against that description and to list anything they changed or left out. If one quote includes hauling and another does not, the cheaper one may not be cheaper. Visiting the site with each provider is worth the time, because a quote made over the phone usually has hidden assumptions. When a provider asks you a question you had not thought of, write the answer into your description and send it to the others too.
Put the Quotes in Columns
Make a simple grid with one column per provider and one row per cost. Rows might include the base price, fuel, travel or trucking, materials, labor, equipment fees, minimum charges, disposal, and any extras. Fill each box, and write "not included" where it applies. Then total each column. Here is a worked example. Say you need 300 acres of custom work. Provider A quotes 18 dollars per acre, which is 5,400 dollars, plus a 600 dollar move-on charge, totaling 6,000. Provider B quotes 20 dollars per acre, which is 6,000, with move-on included, also totaling 6,000. The cheaper rate was not the cheaper job. These numbers only illustrate the arithmetic. Real rates vary, so check university Extension custom rate surveys for local ranges.
Understand How Each Is Priced
A quote may be per acre, per hour, per load, per head, a lump sum or time and materials. Each shifts risk differently. A fixed price puts more risk on the provider. Time and materials puts more on you. Ask what makes the number change, and ask for a not-to-exceed figure on any hourly job. Convert each quote to a common unit so you can compare, such as dollars per acre or dollars per ton. If the unit is hours, ask how many hours the provider expects and how they arrived at that. A very low hourly rate paired with a slow crew can cost more than a higher rate with a fast one.
Look at Timing and Risk, Not Just Price
A cheaper provider who arrives three weeks late can cost you more in lost yield or missed marketing windows than the savings were worth. Ask each provider when they can start, how long the job will take, and what happens if weather delays them. Consider the provider's insurance, license status and references as part of the comparison. If one provider has no insurance and another does, the quotes are not for the same service. Weigh also the cost of your own time. A provider who needs constant supervision costs you hours that a more experienced crew would not.
Watch for Quotes That Are Too Good
A quote far below the others usually means something. The provider may be leaving out costs, using lower quality materials, cutting corners, or planning to raise the price once the work begins. Ask the low bidder to walk through how they reached the number. If the answer is vague, or if they push you to decide today, be careful. Equally, the highest quote is not always the best. Ask what you get for the extra money. Sometimes it is better equipment, more insurance or a firm schedule. Sometimes it is just a high price.
Get the Final Number in Writing
Once you have chosen, ask the provider to issue a written quote that lists the scope, the price, the payment terms, the start date and the exclusions. Check that it matches what was said on the phone. Keep the competing quotes on file. If a dispute comes up, they show what the market looked like at the time. Rules about quotes, estimates and binding contracts vary by state, so ask an attorney if the job is large.
Find providers near you
Pick your state to see vets, custom operators, dealers, elevators and other farm services.
