Farm service guides and a state-by-state directory for farmers and ranchersA farm.FM network site · Farm news →
AgServicesDirectoryWho to call, state by state
Home › Guides › Farm Labor & Crew Services › Managing Contractor Performance

Managing Contractor Performance

Hiring a good contractor is half the work. The other half is setting clear expectations, checking the results and keeping records that back you up.

Farm Labor & Crew Services3 min read728 words

In short

  • Write a one-page scope that says what done looks like, who supervises and what weather does.
  • Inspect early, take dated notes and raise problems the same day in writing.
  • Review each job afterward and keep notes on who to call back.

Define the job before the job starts

Most performance problems are expectation problems. Before work begins, write down what done looks like. For a custom harvest crew, that might be the fields, the acreage, the target moisture range, the maximum acceptable loss and the deadline. For a fencing contractor it might be line, post spacing, brace type and gate placement. Put it on a page both sides sign. Add who supervises, who is the contact when the farm owner is away, and what happens when weather stops work. A clear scope is a courtesy to the contractor as much as protection for you.

Pick a few things to measure

You cannot track everything, so choose measures that matter for the job. Examples: acres finished per day compared with the plan, quality of work such as stand count, spray coverage or seed depth, adherence to label directions, cleanliness of equipment moving between farms, communication, and safety. For a labor crew you might add punctuality and a rate of rework. Decide ahead of time how you will check each one. A walk behind the crew, a spot check of the field, or a look at the contractor's own logs can each do the job without insulting anyone.

Check early and check often

Inspect the first hour or the first field, not the last. Walk the work with the operator or crew leader and point out anything off while it is cheap to fix. Take photos with a date stamp, and make short notes: field, what you saw, who you told and when. If a pattern shows up, talk about it that day. Waiting until the invoice arrives turns a minor correction into a dispute. Praise what is done well too. Good contractors talk to each other, and the farm that treats people fairly gets called back first.

Handle problems in writing

When something goes wrong, call first and then follow with a short email or text summarizing what was said. State what happened, what the agreement says, and what you want done and by when. Keep the tone calm and factual. Ask the contractor for their side, because sometimes the weather, a breakdown or an unclear instruction is the real cause. If the problem involves damage, a spray drift complaint or an injury, tell your insurance agent promptly and check any required reporting with your state department of agriculture or other agency. Do not withhold payment for something the contract does not allow you to withhold.

Pay, review and decide

Pay on the schedule you agreed on, and dispute only the part that is actually disputed. At the end of the job, sit down for ten minutes and review: scope met, quality, timeliness, communication, safety, and total cost against the estimate. Write a few lines in your file. Over several seasons these notes become your own record of who to call back, who to call early and who to retire from the list. Extension custom-rate information can help you judge whether a price was in line, though rates vary by region and job.

Know when to part ways

Stop the arrangement when the contractor repeatedly misses the standard, ignores safety or the label, or will not communicate. Check the termination terms in your agreement first and follow them, giving written notice as required. Document the reasons, collect any of your property and keep copies of everything. If money is owed in either direction, settle it in writing. Rules on disputes and liens vary by state, so call an attorney if the amount is large. Leave the door open if you can; farming is a small world.

A simple scorecard

Many farms keep a half-page scorecard for each contractor, filled out in five minutes at the end of a job. List the items you care about, give each a rating from one to five and add a line of comment. Over three or four jobs a pattern appears that no single memory would give you. Share the card with the contractor if the relationship is a good one; most people would rather hear what you think than guess. Keep it in the same folder as the agreement and invoices.

Find providers near you

Pick your state to see vets, custom operators, dealers, elevators and other farm services.

Keep reading