In short
- Match the credential and method to the purpose: land appraisal, equipment appraisal, or whole business.
- Ask for a sample report, the method used, and how family labor and leases are treated.
- Put purpose, scope, fee, and who may rely on the report in the engagement letter.
When you need a valuation
Most farmers think about value only when something forces the question. A buyout between siblings, a divorce, an estate, a new partner, a loan request, or a sale all call for a defensible number. A valuation is different from an appraisal of land alone. It looks at the business as a whole: land, buildings, machinery, livestock, inventory, leases, contracts, debt, and the earning power of the operation. Which of those pieces matter depends on whether the business is being sold, split, or passed on. Be clear with the provider about the purpose, because the right method and the final number depend on it.
Who does the work
Land is typically valued by a state licensed or certified real estate appraiser, ideally one with rural experience. Machinery and equipment may be valued by an equipment appraiser or a dealer familiar with local markets. Livestock may call for an experienced appraiser or sale barn professional. Whole business valuations are often done by accountants or valuation specialists who hold credentials from recognized professional bodies. Credentials and licensing rules vary by state, so check with your state appraisal board and ask the provider to show you proof. Farm Credit lenders and Extension farm management specialists can sometimes point you to people who have done this work for farms.
Methods in plain terms
Three approaches show up most often. The asset approach adds up what the pieces would bring and subtracts debt. The income approach looks at what the operation earns over time and what that earning stream is worth. The market approach compares to similar sales. A good report explains which it used and why. Ask how they adjust for family labor that is not paid a market wage, and how they treat owner draw. Ask how they handle government payments and crop insurance, and how they treat leased ground, since leases may not transfer.
Questions before you hire
Ask what is included in the report and what it will be used for. Ask for a sample, with the client name removed. Ask how long it will take and what records they need. Ask how many farm valuations they have done and in what type of operation. Ask whether they will testify or explain the work to a lender, attorney, or family member if asked, and at what rate. Ask how they handle conflict of interest. A provider who also stands to profit from the sale is not a neutral source.
What to put in writing
Get an engagement letter that states the purpose, the date of value, the scope, the fee, the delivery date, and who may rely on the report. A report prepared for a loan may not suit a family buyout or a court. Fees vary with the size and complexity of the operation. Avoid any fee tied to the value they reach. If your attorney or accountant is involved, have them review the scope before you sign.
Use the number wisely
A valuation is a snapshot. Prices for land, grain, and cattle move, and a number that was fair last season may not be next season. Read the assumptions section, since a small change there can move the result a lot. If two heirs disagree, a neutral report from someone both trust is worth the fee. Keep the report with your estate and succession papers and update it when something major changes.
Ask how the provider will treat things that do not show on a balance sheet, such as a favorable long term lease, a contract with a premium buyer, or a good reputation with a landlord. Some of these carry real value and some disappear when the owner leaves. Also ask how they deal with machinery that is old but still working. Book value and what a dealer would pay can be far apart, and the report should say which one it uses.
Find providers near you
Pick your state to see vets, custom operators, dealers, elevators and other farm services.
